Fair Work Anonymous Complaints: Would Your Records Pass an Audit?
You may never know that an employee has reported your business to the Fair Work Ombudsman.
There may be no formal grievance, uncomfortable meeting or warning from the employee. They can submit an anonymous report and continue turning up to work as usual.
In 2025 - 2026, the Fair Work Ombudsman received a record 31,596 anonymous reports, a 23% increase on the previous year. It also issued 791 infringement notices and warned employers that payslip and record-keeping breaches remain a significant compliance problem. According to the FWO’s latest annual results, it recovered $453 million for more than 181,000 workers during the year.
The uncomfortable question for business owners is therefore not:
“Would one of my employees complain?”
It is:
“If they already have, could I prove that we paid them correctly?”

Could you actually prove it?
Here's something many business owners don't realise.
Under the Fair Work Act, employers must keep accurate employment records for seven years.
And if an employee claims they've been underpaid, but your business hasn't kept the required records, the burden of proof can shift to you.
In other words, you may have to prove the employee's claim is wrong, rather than the employee having to prove they've been underpaid.
That's why simply believing you're paying your staff correctly isn't enough.
You need to know which award applies, whether your employees are classified correctly, and whether your payroll and timekeeping records demonstrate that they've received all their legal entitlements.
And that's where award classifications come in.
What is an Award?
Think of an award as a detailed rulebook for a specific industry or occupation.
It tells you:
Which roles it covers
The minimum pay rates for each classification level
when overtime applies
How breaks must be structured
What penalties, loadings and allowances must be paid
Rostering rules and notice periods
Consultation requirements for any major workplace changes
Every employee covered by an award must receive at least what the award promises. You can go above it, but you cannot go below.
The links below will help you to identify which Award your business and your employees could fall under.
If you aren't sure and need help, get in touch.
Getting it right now will save you from major headaches in the future.
What is a Classification?
Inside every award is a classification structure. It sets out the skill level, experience, qualifications and responsibilities for each role.
For example:
A hospitality worker might be classified at different levels depending on their duties, skills, experience and supervisory responsibilities.
An admin employee could be Level 1 to 5 under the Clerks Award
A nurse might be Level 1 to 7 depending on qualifications and duties
Matching your employee to the correct classification level ensures they are paid at the right level and receive the correct entitlements.
The link below will explain a bit more about classifications and help you to identify the right one:
Why award classification matters so much
Classification drives an important part of your staff pay structure.
If you classify someone too low, you may be underpaying them.
And it also affects more than just pay:
1. Underpayments are expensive
If Fair Work audits your business or an employee raises a complaint, the business can be liable for:
backpay of all underpaid amounts
interest
additional superannuation
penalties under the Fair Work Act
legal and administrative costs
reputational damage
Underpayments can go back up to 6 years. And we've seen situations where a simple misclassification can end up adding up to tens of thousands of dollars in backpay, and create a serious financial burden for a business.
Since January 2025, deliberately underpaying employees can be a criminal offence.
This doesn't mean an honest payroll mistake will land a business owner in court on criminal charges. However, knowingly paying employees less than their legal entitlements is now a much more serious matter, potentially resulting in criminal prosecution.
For small businesses, the Fair Work Ombudsman's Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code offers protection against criminal referral where the business has complied with the Code. However, businesses can still be required to backpay employees and may face civil penalties.
2. Employees talk
Employees compare payslips and their employment conditions.
'Pay Secrecy' clauses which used to prohibit employees from discussing their compensation with their coworker, are now unlawful. Employees now have certain rights regarding the sharing of information related to their pay and terms and conditions of employment.
If one staff member realises they’re below their correct award level, trust can be broken quickly. You can lose a good employee over something completely fixable.
3. It affects overtime, TOIL and penalty rates
Different classifications sometimes come with different overtime triggers, allowances or weekend penalties. If you get the classification wrong, the whole pay structure may also become wrong.
Paying an employee a salary above the award minimum doesn't automatically mean you've met all your obligations. Recent Federal Court decisions have reinforced the importance of correctly accounting for overtime, penalties and other entitlements in each pay period. Employers need to ensure their salary arrangements, contracts and payroll practices comply with the applicable rules.
4. It protects you during disputes
If an employee ever disputes their rate or role, you need to show how you came to the classification:
Which award they fall under
Why that award applies
Why you selected that classification level
Which duties or qualifications align
If you can demonstrate a clear, logical process, you’re starting on the right foot.
How misclassification happens
Businesses rarely misclassify staff intentionally. It usually happens because:
A position changes over time, for example an admin assistant slowly becomes office manager
The business uses a generic contract template without checking the award
The employee’s duties don’t match what the job title
Someone promoted internally isn’t reclassified
The award itself is misunderstood
The role is hybrid, for example admin plus marketing plus customer service, and the business picks the wrong award
How to correctly classify an employee
1. Identify the correct award or enterprise agreement
Check:
Industry, for example Hospitality, Horticulture, Building
Occupation, for example Nurses, Clerks, Retail
Role duties, not job titles
Coverage clauses within awards
If 2 awards appear to apply, check their coverage and exclusion rules, as well as the employee’s actual duties, to determine which award applies. Also check whether an enterprise agreement covers the employee.
2. Match the role to the classification descriptions
Look for:
Skill requirements
Level of supervision needed
Level of responsibility
Qualifications
Decision-making authority
Duties performed regularly
Find the closest match. This becomes your classification.
3. Document your reasoning
Create a short file note including:
Award selected
Classification level
Why it matches
Duties considered
Any qualifications or experience relevant
This protects you in case of a future dispute.
4. Make sure the contract matches the award
Your employment contract should:
Name the award
Name the exact classification level
Confirm the pay rate meets or exceeds the award
Set out overtime, penalties or salary arrangements clearly
The employment contract and award must align and work together.
5. Review classifications annually or when roles change
If an employee steps up, for example training others, managing, supervising, handling money or operating equipment, they may need reclassification.
And remember to keep on top of the changing pay rates for each classification; these usually occur in July each year.
What to do if you’ve been using the wrong classification
Discovering that an employee has been incorrectly classified doesn't necessarily mean you're facing a major problem, but it's important to act promptly. The sooner you identify and correct an issue, the easier it is to prevent further underpayments.
Reclassify the employee correctly
Check for underpayments and calculate the gap
Backpay the gap, and don't forget super
Explain the correction openly and transparently
Update the contract to the correct level
Fix any rostering or payroll issues going forward
Taking prompt steps to investigate and correct underpayments can demonstrate a genuine commitment to compliance, although voluntary correction doesn't automatically remove the risk of penalties.
If you want help checking whether your team is correctly classified or you’d like a simple HR Health Check for your business, we offer a practical, fixed-fee review that gives you clarity, compliance and peace of mind.
Book a free discovery call today, and let’s explore how we can take the HR off your plate, so you can focus on growing your business.
Need help? Contact us today - sandra@hrconsultingtas.com.au or 0408 408 225
DISCLAIMER:
The content provided on this website serves as a general information resource on the subjects discussed, and should not be considered tailored to specific individual circumstances or a replacement for legal counsel. While we exert significant effort to ensure the accuracy of our information, HR Consulting TAS cannot ensure that all content on this website is consistently accurate, exhaustive, or current. Recommendations by HR Consulting TAS and any information acquired from this website should not be regarded as legal advice.




Comments